Aluminum Shell Chair vs Saddle Leather Arm Chair
By Heath Ceramics | Curated Home Goods | Sustainably Handcrafted | Published: 2026-10-22
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Aluminum Shell Chair and Saddle Leather Arm Chair to find the right modern seating for your space. We break down style, durability, and trade-offs.
Quick answer
Choose the Aluminum Shell Chair for a playful, budget-friendly statement piece that works indoors or out, or the Saddle Leather Arm Chair for a rugged, heirloom-quality seat with a longer wait and higher price.
Style and material differences
The Aluminum Shell Chair is a contemporary take on a classic mid-century form—modern and rustic at the same time. Its turquoise base adds a fun pop of color, making it a natural conversation starter. The Saddle Leather Arm Chair, by contrast, uses vegetable-tanned saddle-grade leather and wooden arms, giving it a refined ruggedness that looks just as good outdoors as it does in a living room.
Lead time and price trade-off
Price difference is significant: the Saddle Leather Arm Chair is listed at $1,419 (compared to $2,150), while the Aluminum Shell Chair is $692.25 (compared to $975). But the leather chair also requires a 10-12 week delivery window, so if you need seating sooner, the Aluminum Shell Chair is the faster option.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Price vs. investment: The Aluminum Shell Chair is more affordable ($692.25) and available sooner; the Saddle Leather Arm Chair costs more ($1,419) but uses premium materials that age well.
- Indoor vs. indoor/outdoor: The Saddle Leather Arm Chair is designed to work both indoors and outdoors thanks to its saddle leather and stance. The Aluminum Shell Chair is best kept indoors or on a covered porch. If you need a chair that can live on a patio or in a sunroom, the leather chair is the better choice.
- Style statement: The Aluminum Shell Chair makes a playful, colorful statement; the Saddle Leather Arm Chair offers a more rugged, timeless look.
Product facts at a glance
- Saddle Leather Arm Chair in Black with Black Satin Base: The wooden arms, vegetable tanned saddle grade leather, and the 'stance' of the Sling chair design by Garza Marfa looks right at home outdoors, and brings a refined ruggedness indoors. Please note that this product takes 10-12 weeks for delivery. This chair is built for longevity and can handle both indoor and covered outdoor use, but you'll need to plan ahead for the lead time.
Saddle Leather Arm Chair in Black with Black Satin Base - Aluminum Shell Chair with Turquoise Base: This fun chair is a contemporary take on a classic mid-century form. At once modern and rustic, this chair makes a fun statement for any room. Its lighter weight and lower price make it an easy choice for adding personality without a long wait.
Aluminum Shell Chair with Turquoise Base
Which chair fits you?
Best for
- Budget-conscious shoppers who want a fun, modern accent chair without a long wait
- Anyone needing a quick delivery or a lighter-weight seat
Not for
- Those wanting a chair that can live outdoors in the elements—choose the Saddle Leather Arm Chair instead
- Shoppers looking for a heirloom piece with a patina that develops over time
